Moons Like Earth's Moon are Rare in the Universe
Introduction
Proponents of intelligent design claim that the universe, Milky Way Galaxy, Solar System, and earth are specifically designed by an intelligent agent for habitation by human beings. Others say that such claims amount to a God of the gaps argument, since scientists do not yet have answers for the apparent design of the universe. If the skeptics of intelligent design are correct, then science should be finding that we do not occupy any special place in the universe. However, a new study disputes the idea that earth's moon is just an ordinary moon.
Formation of the Moon
Scientists now know that the Moon was formed by the collision of the small planet with the earth, which resulted in the ejection of 5 billion cubic miles of the earth's crust and mantle into orbit around the earth. This ring of material, the theory states, would eventually coalesce to form the moon. In addition, the moon is moving away from the earth (currently at 2 inches per year), as is predicted by the theory. If we calculate backwards, we discover that the moon must have formed just outside the Roche limit, the point at which an object would be torn apart by the earth's gravity (7,300 miles above the earth's surface). A collision which would have ejected material less than the Roche limit would have formed only rings around the earth. Computer models show that a collision of a small planet with the earth must have been very precise in order for any moon to have been formed at all.
The new study
When a moon is formed by the kind of collision that formed Earth's Moon, dust would have been blasted throughout the solar system. Astronomer Nadya Gorlova of the University of Florida, Gainesville, decided to study newly forming stars to determine what percentage might have a moon that formed through one of these massive collision events.2 In examining 400 newly formed stars (30 million years old), only one shared characteristics that would suggest that such a large collision had occurred, which might form a moon. Of course, the probability that the newly formed moon would orbit an earth like planet within the habitable zone would be much less likely.
Conclusion 
Although
no earth-like planets have been detected yet, it is likely that they do exist.
However, it is unlikely that such earths would have a moon the size of
Earth's moon, since such a pair could not coalesce together, nor could such a
moon be captured by a small planet like the earth. Therefore, the only means by
which such a moon could form would be through a collision event early in the
history of stellar formation. In the first study to examine the probability of
such a formation, a new study shows that only one in 400 new stars might
have formed such a moon through a collision event. Why is it important how the
moon was formed? Without such a large moon, earth's rotation axis would be
unstable, swinging through 90� or more, resulting in extremely variable climate
over its history. In addition, the collision event itself blew off earth's heavy
early greenhouse atmosphere, which allowed the planet to retain its water for
billions of years. The removal of much of the earth's crust also allowed the
earth to retain its tectonic activity for billions of years, which allowed for
the existence of both land and ocean. Without such tectonic activity, earth
would have become and remained a waterworld. For more information, see
The Incredible Design of the Earth and Our Solar System.
Astronomy and cosmology continue to provide evidence that the earth is not just
an ordinary planet in an ordinary solar system.
Related Resources
Rare
Earth: Why Complex Life is Uncommon in the Universe by Peter D. Ward and
Donald Brownlee
A secular book (2000) that recognizes the improbable design of the earth. Paleontologist Peter D. Ward and astrobiologist Donald Brownlee examine the unusual characteristics of our galaxy, solar system, star, and Earth and conclude that ET may have no home to go to. Surprisingly, the authors conclude that the amazing "coincidences" are the result of good luck and chance.
The
Creator and the Cosmos by Dr.
Hugh Ross
A classic book by astronomer Hugh Ross on modern Christian apologetics and science, (updated June, 2001). Dr. Ross presents the latest scientific evidence for intelligent design of our world and an easy to understand introduction to modern cosmology. This is a great book to give agnostics, who have an interest in cosmology and astronomy.
References
- Taylor, G. Jeffrey. July, 1994. "The scientific
legacy of Apollo" Scientific American 271 (1): 40-47.
Giant Impact Theory For Moon Formation Boosted (from SpaceDaily.com) - Gorlova, N., Z. Balog, G. H. Rieke, J. Muzerolle, K. Y. L. Su, V. D. Ivanov, and E. T. Young. 2007. Debris Disks in NGC 2547. The Astrophysical Journal 670: 516-535.
Today's New Reason to Believe
Integrating Science and Faith
- 05/17/2012 10:23 AM
TNRTB Classic: Skeletons in the Cambrian Explosion
A few days ago, I wrote about a recent discovery that highlights the challenge that specific features of the Cambrian explosion pose for the evolutionary paradigm. This discovery is not the first of its kind. Over the last couple of decades a number of findings call attention to the difficulties the Cambrian explosion creates for … Read more
() - 05/14/2012 11:23 AM
Pikaia Fossils Explode the Evolutionary Paradigm
A recent campaign by the Royal Ontario Museum to collect more fossils from the Burgess Shale site in the Canadian Rockies has added to the number of fossil specimens of a highly enigmatic creature called Pikaia gracilens. Taking advantage of the new fossils, two paleontologists interpreted Pikaia to be a member of the phylum Chordata. … Read more
() - 05/10/2012 12:07 AM
TNRTB Classic: Searching for Dark Energy
Earlier this week, I commented on dark energy’s impact on the fine-tuning argument for a Creator. For years, astronomers have hoped for direct detection of dark energy and the other dark “stuff” of the universe. Below is a link to RTB articles that have tracked with this exciting research for almost a decade. “RTB’s Dark … Read more
() - 05/07/2012 04:05 PM
Honing in on Dark Energy Design
The Supernova Cosmology Project has achieved the most precise measurement of the universe’s dark energy density. The team’s measurements also yield the strongest evidence yet that a cosmological constant provides the best explanation for dark energy. Increasingly accurate measurements of the quantity and character of dark energy provide an ever-stronger case for the supernatural design … Read more
() - 05/04/2012 09:24 AM
TNRTB Classic: Awesome Science
On Monday I profiled four discoveries that, while they may not have an apologetics application, are just too cool or interesting to ignore. I’ve covered other such findings in previous TNRTB posts. Check out these articles for more fun scientific discoveries. “Cool Discoveries, Part 1” “Cool Discoveries, Part 2” “Cool Discoveries, Part 3”
() - 04/30/2012 12:15 AM
More Cool Discoveries
Occasionally research shows up that may not have any immediate apologetics interest but falls into the “too-cool” category. This installment includes cave formations that track past earthquakes (and possibly predict future ones), light-harvesting hornet shells, a clock accurate to one second every million years, and self-healing, autonomous materials. **** Earthquake Trackers Over the past few … Read more
() - 04/26/2012 10:10 AM
Article Highlight: An Old-Earth Creation Model for the Origin of Humanity
What is it to be human? This is an important question. Perhaps it is the most important question we could ever ask. The answer has profound and wide-ranging implications. In many respects, this question can’t be adequately addressed unless we examine a more fundamental question, “Where do humans come from?” In the West, influenced by … Read more
() - 04/23/2012 03:40 PM
Did God Create Using Evolutionary Processes?
American botanist Asa Gray was one of the first scientists in the United States to adopt and promote Darwin’s theory of biological evolution. Gray was also an orthodox Christian, who saw no conflict between a history of life on Earth that was the outworking of evolutionary processes and the Christian faith. Gray was perhaps one … Read more
() - 04/19/2012 09:38 AM
TNRTB Classic: Oxygenation Events
Humans and other large-bodied organisms, even some single-celled organisms, require free oxygen for survival. For most of Earth’s history, all the planet’s oxygen was locked away in other compounds. Around 2.5 billion years ago, oxygen established a more permanent foothold (with some instability) in the atmosphere, and it rose to current values around half-a-billion years … Read more
() - 04/16/2012 02:04 PM
A Hazy Atmosphere on Early Earth
Most scientists think Earth’s early atmosphere looked similar to that of today—dominated by nitrogen and carbon dioxide, largely transparent, and having clouds scattered across the globe. This view contrasts with RTB’s model where Earth’s early atmosphere was translucent (rather than transparent) such that the Sun, Moon, and stars could not be seen regularly from Earth’s … Read more
()
http://www.godandscience.org/apologetics/earth_moons_rare.html
Last updated November 23, 2007
Top of Page 
Back